The highly-anticipated sequel of Megan and her alpha-werewolf mate Zack continues. Picking up where Bewitching the Werewolf ended, Megan has the unfortunate realization that good sex and a hot guy does not guarantee a happily ever after.

Fleeing back to her life in NYC she gets a new case. A librarian, a vampire and a were-hamster go missing and what should be the start of a bad joke turns into a deadly situation as Megan discovers that her personal and professional life might not be as far apart as they seem.