Charming orthopedics doctor Clark Baker is known for being a big flirt. He loves women, they love him and he's never lacked for dates. But he's ready to settle down now and find a serious relationship, and the one person he sets his sights on, bookstore manager, Tammy Burns, does not take him seriously.

She likes him quite a bit. He's easy to like. But in her opinion, Clark is simply not boyfriend material. She dated someone like him a long time ago and he cheated on her. She's not going to make that mistake again. So, she takes her friend Anna's advice, somewhat reluctantly, and decides to try a new dating site, Soulmates. And that's when things really get interesting....